The ULTIMATE Face-Off! Brooke & Payton Are FIERCE Competitors! (S4 Flashback) | Dance Moms

i love how no matter how much the moms fight they always stick up for each other and each others kids !

Sorry but we can’t compare Payton’s solo to Brooke’s. Payton’s was mostly some random steps that literally everybody can do. Brooke’s was breathtaking and not everybody can do this. Brooke definitely deserved this win.

Brooke lost. Its a shame.

Brooke is better then maddie

as a dancer myself i believe that brooke should’ve won bc of the fantastic costume design and also she had more acro in the dance and was more great then payton sorry it’s my opinion but also Leslie (payton’s mom) is a pretty rude mom if you ask me but Kelly (brooke’s mum) is a really tough and kind woman honestly BROOKE HYLAND SHOULD HAVE WON!!!❤️😊

ik im a year late but brooke is so pretty

I like how brook got a 396 out of 300 😂

That’s was nice help Abby Payton Brooke jealous

Brooke deserves to be better than Payton

I think Brooke is a great dancer and Shouldn’t be replaced . Brooke Acts lazy or bored sometimes But she’s a pretty girl and a great dancer
She Definitely deserves to be on that team and stay on that team .

Every parent should think their child is the best, it’s the teacher who is supposed to give them the same chances, but teachers all play favourites no matter what they admit to or not.

Brooke or payton

Were all talking about how abbys fav is maddie did we evee ask who Gianas favourite dancer is🤔

"Oh gawd" -Kelly

Group got first place. Payton got second place. Brooke got third. That's all. Brooke would have gotten first, if she would have tied Abby's shoes together as Jill suggested earlier. 😁☺️

I think Brooke and payton look like gia

Where was christi and Chloe?

Holly is so😂😂

I honestly didnt mind payton but I hated lesilie

Brook should’ve won 1st place and not 3rd in my opinion paytons dance was terrible but I loved brooks dance

I know im gonna get hate but i like payton

I can see Payton didn't have enough emotions and she's pigone toed no offense I think Brooke should have won

“Oh gawd”

Ni dont say sorry brooke deserves that win

I can't believe I have never seen this before. Brooke was so much better than Payton

Pretty clear that Leslie just wanted to be on the show. Why would a talented 15 year old dancer want to be a on a team with dancers 4 and 5 years younger than her? But then again, the senior team isn't on TV. So, there you go.

I love brooke more than payton

Bro no competition brook wins in mums and who is a better dancer (if you disagree sorry don’t hate I don’t know what I’m saying but in my opinion Brooke is better)

Abby is so preppy! very demure very cutesy

Gurl the way kelly was staring at Brooke during the solo scared me

Completely honest, I think that Maddie actually had the most trauma. She was so pressured and I felt so bad.

Completely honest, I think that Maddie actually had the most trauma. She was so pressured and I felt so bad.

Bro😊

Payton looked like a hot mess..sorry...

HALF A POINT HIGHER...

Payton flipped and flopped on the stage😂😂😂

I don’t honestly like Payton….

I generally think Payton is a great dancer but.. I don't understand how she won. The technical aspect of her routine was extremely easy. Brookes was MUCH harder. And she just wasn't up to par here, the lack of flexibility, her leg on those turns wasn't up high enough... I just don't get it. Brooke would have won if that wasn't rigged. No judge would score Payton higher for that particular performance.

SHUT UP LESLIE

They are both great dancers but brooke showed way more passion and was way better.

Nobody replaces the original.

I feel like in the beginning of season 4 the hylands and abby’s relationship slowly (and i mean SLOWLY) started to heal but then The Fight happened….

What is this episode😊

Hands down brookes best solo