Комментарии:
❤
ОтветитьIt is not just an ancient claim. It is a continuous claim. Despite the Romans, and so on.
ОтветитьBreakfast! That's how long ago?
ОтветитьThe Palestinians does not go back further than 1948. Jewish present go back thousands of years
ОтветитьWhats wrong with a 2 state solution? You have to understand both sides to come to a conclusion.
ОтветитьChildren ! Whats horrific is children regardless of any belief are the innocents throughout history and continue to be so! Any jdeal , or religion that weaponises children can never be accepted !
ОтветитьBoth Islam and Christianity depend on, grow out of, and incorporate into their religions the Old Testament. All three accept that they worship the "same God" and are "children of Abraham". How then can anyone logically or with any internal coherence deny the Jews their homeland as it is ordained by the same God?
ОтветитьYes' OK, Islam came to the region 1400 years ago only. But the Palestinians claim, and at least somewhat rightfully so, that they were the people of the land before Islam, and that they converted to Islam, and before that' they were still the people of this land, whether they were Christians, pagans and Jews before, and this is a valid claim, to those who actually lived here for generations, and are not work immigrants that immigrated here over the years . I have no problem accepting that and share the land with them, if they are willing to accept that I also have a claim to the land as a Jew. Bu their claim is that European people, converts from eastern Europe, Kazars, came to the land and claimed it as their own. Colonialized it. Now, that's a claim that migth have some merit, but definitely not for all the Jews and definitely not when so many of the so called Palestinians also don't have any connection to the land, and it's ignoring the centuries long connections of the Jews to the land that is so well documented in the history of the world. The problem is they WILL NOT aknowledge any connection of the Jews to the land.
ОтветитьGod bless 🇮🇱🙏🙏🙏❤️🇮🇱🙏
ОтветитьI agree with Ron Dermer's argument on the right of the Jews to return to their ancestrial land! I wish the Kurds would be allowed to have their own nation state too! 25-40m people living as minorities across four countries denied the same opportunity doesn't seem right to me!
ОтветитьHow pathetic to’negotiate for kidnapped when normalcy would demand weakening the enemy into submission! Obviously Mr Dermer has NOT been successful. No wonder…
ОтветитьPeople need to understand Arabs and Islam
Islam dictates Arab politics they are inseparable
that is Arab downfall - unwillingness to change😎
Ron Dermer is the minister for hostage release? Doing a bang up job! Trump and Witkoff got 30 back? How many did Ron get back?
ОтветитьAnd Biblical Truth! This land was given to Israel, by GOD!
Ответитьאמן ואמן
עם ישראל חי 🇮🇱
Every time they are screaming, CHAIBAR, CHAIBAR YA YAHUD, refresh their memory!!! They know who we are, but the culture who brought us "Tells of thousands nights" just cannot admit true facts, as the honorable ambassador rightly pointed out.
ОтветитьYou are creating a history for the Jewish people. Judaism is, a religion, never were a nation nor did they have a state
ОтветитьBull shit !
ОтветитьAdmitting Jews have a history in the Middle East pre Islam would be admitting from a historical perspective that a claim by a people predates theirs unless they can establish that they were Canaanites with a religion different than Islam. But Islam according to islamists is actually a successor religion that as its ultimate objective is establishing a world Caliphate. The historical argument does not work for them. As long as Israel exists the argument that Islam should control the world when it cannot control the Middle East does not stand from a political perspective or even a legal one.
ОтветитьThe headline says "Watch Peterson visibly stunned..." - but where is Peterson's reaction to the last statement we hear? It's not shown, so how can we know if he's "visibly stunned"? I wish if people make such claims, that they prove it by showing the reaction they claim to have occurred.
ОтветитьGene analysis proves that less than 3% of today's Jews are descended form the Israelites who INVADED Canaan about 3100 years ago. Most Palestinians have DNA from before that invasion.
ОтветитьIsrael has their Land from Th Creator of the Universe!!!!!
ОтветитьPeterson maybe spoke out of partial context - NO ONE lived in North America 'originally.' 101% crossed a land bridge from Siberia.
Otherwise an interesting report; strange there aren't many more views (yet).
Of course it does, there should be no debate at all
Ответить75% of that original mandate was given over to the Hashemite kingdom, called Jordan. Most of Jordan is Palestinian. Nobody is asking the Palestinians to move, but do us a favor and take Jordanian citizenship, and vote in their essentially meaningless elections. So Israel isn't entitled to a portion of that left over 25%? That is the essence of antisemitism. No, we aren't entitled to live anywhere. WW11 certainly proved that.
ОтветитьTo admit that Jews have this long history is to essentially knock out the Palestinian claim. Some Palestinians, not so many, are descended from Arabs who lived in what is Israel for hundreds of years, but many descend from ancestor who arrived in the 1920s to 1947, and the British turned a blind eye to this while refusing to allow Jews in, even after the Holocaust.
ОтветитьYour religion is based on a real estate deal.
ОтветитьI don't care
ОтветитьHa ! “Were the Indians that came back” ! That’s the greatest thing I have heard !
ОтветитьTHIS IS A FANTASTIC VIDEO !!!! WATCH IT !!!!
Ответить"proof"?!?
No, this is outrageous & preposterous!
That's right a Jew born in New York has a right to live in Palestine, but a Palestinian born in Jerusalem has no right to his homeland.
ОтветитьRather odd to hear a rabbi discussing the notion of "rejectionism" when that single characteristic best describes an entire two-millennia zeitgeist of "Judaism." (And btw, Dr. Peterson, "begging the question" doesn't mean ANTICIPATING the question.)
ОтветитьSTOP THE KILLING. AMERICAS SHOULD GIVE THE LAND BACK TO NATIVE TRIBES IN AMERICA IF THE LOGIC OF ISRAEL OWNS THE LAND OF PALESTINE IS TRUE.
ОтветитьVery good!
ОтветитьThe Gazans lost a war. They refuse to accept the consequences of that too.
ОтветитьDivisive bullshit
ОтветитьYou don’t think it’s very telling that the entire world throughout history has turned their backs on this one people. What manners or lack there of do they have? What behaviors are they exercising such that every country they go in wants them out
ОтветитьTo my Jewish Friends:
“The stone which the builders rejected Has become the chief cornerstone.”
Psalms 118:22 NKJV
“Have you not even read this Scripture: ‘The stone which the builders rejected Has become the chief cornerstone.”
Mark 12:10 NKJV
“let it be known to you all, and to all the people of Israel, that by the name of Jesus Christ of Nazareth, whom you crucified, whom God raised from the dead, by Him this man stands here before you whole. This is the ‘stone which was rejected by you builders, which has become the chief cornerstone.’ Nor is there salvation in any other, for there is no other name under heaven given among men by which we must be saved.””
Acts 4:10-12 NKJV
On May 14, 1948, the State of Israel was established. So who was the first in these lands? Free Palestine
i want add something
according to old speech and documentary
it was palestine you can check famous hitler speech and other worldwide government speech and many old documentary you will see Palestine state not zionist regime
zionist and nazis are two sides of the sams coin
ОтветитьThe most sad and heartbreaking thing is.. they ( israelis) are targeting CHILDREN!
Speak up people, boycott, please share anything, dont stay silence.
Ismail Haniyeh**
"Resistance is a legitimate right of occupied people. We will never surrender our land or our dignity to the Zionist occupation."
Israel and the Jews have a separate and distinct history.cannot be compared to other nations.
ОтветитьAnother big problem for the "Palestinians", besides the extremely persuasive case made in this video by the former Israeli Ambassador to the United
States is that Israelis both inside and outside the government are so damned articulate and bright that in any debate they just intellectually anihilate their Antisemitic antagonists like a hot knife slicing through butter. True, they go into the lion's den armed with a logically superior argument backed up with incontrovertible archeological evidence, persuasive historical facts, and decisive battlefield victories in the half dozen existential wars they've fought since 1948, but guys like Ron Dermer, Douglas Murray, Dennis Prager, Melanie Phillips, Einat Wilf, Alan Dershowitz, Dan Schueftan, Ben Shapiro and Caroline Glick are so smart and articulate that they just mop the floor with their pro-Hamas debate opponents. It's never a fair fight....thank God!
An American Gentile Non-escatological Zionist here who stands with Israel 100% ❤🐻🙏🇺🇲🇮🇱
Jesus ended Judaism there is no such thing anymore it's a fake religion it's expired the Jews do no longer have the blessings of Abraham only those who believe Christ
ОтветитьJerusalem is the home of Christianity, it is our ancestral Homeland
ОтветитьHow do you negotiate with someone who has a gun pointing a gun to your head
ОтветитьPeterson, who are the Palestines? I know who the Panestinians are, but I've never heard of Palestines.
Next point. Arafat, known as the desert rat, was the leader, 35 years ago, of what was called the PLO.. Palestinian Liberation Organization. The virtual philosophical leader was Hanan Ashrawi.
It was ironic the PLO chose the term liberation since Palastinians then, like now, are NOT indigenous people but invaders who, btw, most Israeli jews in Gaza and on the West Bank, befriend and sympathize with. My entire extended family lives there; I kinda get the dynamic.
I was unaware Peterson was antisemitic. A PhD being embarrassed by a man with an undergrad degree from PA, but who is quite brilliant comparatively.
Ответить