Комментарии:
This movie is completely scientifically accurate. You see according to The Theory of Pulmomutis all actions taken by a moon cause interolibreism, or forced pressure diverted away from the atmosphere into the planet. Now before I graduated Stulus Nulla Cum Laude from Havard I never knew most things but a child would know this movie is completely true. No exceptions. Anyways what’s 1 + 1? Oh right 889-99 + 7% of 1,7765^ 23 = [x]<3.
Ответитьi LOVE THIS!! I thought about this the FIRST time I saw The 5th Element (just not so in depth lol)! I thought "but wouldn't this still be bad anyway??" lol and here we go, someone actually did an in depth video about it!! I love this!! This is my favorite video of yours by far!! Overthinkers unite! HA!
ОтветитьThis is similar to my issue with the destruction of the moon in dragonball z
ОтветитьGet Leeloo some more chicken!
Ответить200 Billion citizens
But you're assuming they all live on Earth
Love this movie, flaws and all.
ОтветитьA few dozen or so (my math might be off) of those interstellar drive units from the Flotsam, and it's Alpha Centauri's problem
ОтветитьCould you do a video on whether superman could really stop a tornado?
ОтветитьI’ve also seen this movie about 1000 times and this new moon issue has always left me feeling uneasy every single time.
ОтветитьThunk it thoo
ОтветитьWhat if it were a mere hologram produced by some smaller internal object?
Like the "light bee" in Red Dwarf
I love this, but it cracks me up that you give a physical mass of rock to a molten planet of "evil". What mass does "evil" have? 😂
ОтветитьSo… task failed successfully for Mr. Shadow?
ОтветитьBut the 5 elements were protecting us from those 5 elements.
ОтветитьThis is so dark, i love it
ОтветитьObviously Scotty, your postulate that Mr Shadow had mass is munted. None of these badnessnesses actually happened in the movie. As corroborating evidence, you can see it slowed immediately, and thus had no inertia. Suspend your disbelief, young man. The ultimate weapon might have left it there to remind humans not to be naughty, no more.
ОтветитьI love the humor in this channel. "If the world is going to end, instead of worrying pop a TV dinner in the microwave."
ОтветитьMy favorite movie
Ответитьits greasy evil so it flouts.
ОтветитьNo, you were right in your first interpretation: a floating cork. It wouldn't do for Lelu not to save the world through her magical power of love. Hence, that power must do whatever is needed to save the earth. And thus, it must do exactly what you suggested in the first place, if it doesn't entirely annihilate it from existence --which love doesn't do, but does transform. Therefore, your very first interpretation was the correct one and all the rest just the joy of mental masterbation, however scientifically fun that may be. 😀
Ответитьthis guy is like clickbait for almost smart people like me, we want to learn but then get top 10s and articles about time travellers
ОтветитьLilu Dallas Mulitipass
ОтветитьThe fifth element and back to the future are my all time greats
ОтветитьHow is the Fifth Element the most re-watchable movie ever? What’s the science on that?
Ответить200 Billion - about 20 Billion no doubt live on Mars and 3 Billion live on Space Stations and Ships.
ОтветитьThis is reminding me of a Corridor Crew video. ✨
ОтветитьI did some quick math and if all the fresh water on earth was used to make up the 60% of a human body that is water. the earth could be used to create Approximately 909 quadrillion people. but they would have only the salt water oceans to drink and the land would be a dry wasteland. still suits I guess? the math for keeping enough crops and livestock alive to feed people as well as allow them to drink water is too hard so do a video about it I guess?
ОтветитьAnd Joe Scott, we LOVE that you overthink things.👍
ОтветитьYes, really bad things would happen like mega tsunamis and earthquakes all over the planet and almost definitely all life would end, but I don't think anyone or anything would float towards the evil planet because Earth gravity still would be stronger, and things tend go to where gravity is stronger. Being more lighter because of the counter gravity, definitely.
But the tech in the Fifth Element is very advanced, so let's imagine they towed away the evil planet before some bad stuff could happen, and Leeloo and Dallas lived happily ever after. 😁
This is just one of those movies where you have to turn off the thinking portion of your brain so that you can just enjoy the pretty visuals and sound effects and all of the action sequences.
ОтветитьBro, you couldn't even go into what two moons at a perfect orbit would do to the ecosystem? Tatooine...
ОтветитьOf course the moon is from the last time this happened. It's right there in the shot
ОтветитьSince the film states that the world is saved, I'm gonna go with scenario 3, which you forgot to mention. It isn't either heavenly body stays in orbit or falls to earth. I would argue that it is highly unlikely the beam had only up to the energy needed to bring the object to a halt. It's far more likely that the distance mentioned was the closest Mr. Shadow gets to Earth, not its final position. I'm guessing the beam had enough energy to push the object out of orbital range, and the writers didn't find it necessary to have an irrelevant info dump after the climax of the film. So, while I respect the amount of work you did on this theory, I have to wholeheartedly disagree with your conclusion
ОтветитьI think there is less water on Earth during this time. I remember reading from the creator of this that the reason you see New York City as basically a hive city is that with global warming, they just moved water to other planets, so there is now less water and more land and Earth sources it's water supply form comets. And like a few others have said, there is enough "tech" that as soon as it was smacked stationary, the starfleet would of just started moving it, but I'm sure some damage would of been done before they did
ОтветитьNever cared that much for the fifth element. I keep watching it thinking this is the time I'll like it, but it never happens. It's like a hot girl who's bad in bed, at least IMO. I enjoyed your take on the end, never thought about that. It's more fun to hear critique from fans than haters like myself.
ОтветитьWouldn't all of these doomsday events have happened already at this point?
Like if any planetary object 2% bigger than the moon, got ... almost 4000x closer than the moon, wouldn't they have already been screwed before they save the planet and ... screwed?
And also! How fast was Mr. Shadow moving? Wouldn't there have been some serious structural consequences if something that large, moving at what one can assume is extreme speeds stopped so abruptly? ...
I'm starting to think this wasn't a documentary anymore guys...
This episode reminds me of Bad Astronomy from the early 2000's
ОтветитьI love this movie. Despite its many flaws, it has so many good moments and terrific acting. I never expected an Answers With Joe treatise on it. But yeah, it's so needed. I too thought "wait a minute... that large sphere just sitting in orbit.... that's not good."
ОтветитьI mean, TFE isn't science fiction, its pure fantasy. We are talking about a universe made of only 5 "elements".
They are safe because physics doesn't work like they do in our universe.
"Movies is magic"
ОтветитьYou're tip-toeing (🤷) into Nostalgic territory... MANY people LOVE this movie.. i get it. You're a science guy.. but maybe science and pop (pulp) fiction should be separate 🤷 still love you. Btw
ОтветитьI always thought "What's keeping it up" at the end. I didn't think beyond that though.
ОтветитьThe Star Wars dinner theatre woman singing @ DisneyLand is so from this film. I didn’t go bc Disney Adults? Just a peek @ th what ur getting 4 all that $ 🤯
ОтветитьHow far away would they have had to stop it in order to survive?
ОтветитьMy girl cat is called Leeloo Dallas Multipass ... Multipass
Ответить