Комментарии:
Not your best video to be honest, while the concept could be interesting I found myself actually wanting to see a video about how much these tributes weighted THEN in their economy rather then how much all this gold would be worth NOW.
Still enjoyable though
What were their sources of raw gold?
ОтветитьAll the kings who received tribute from Rome spent that money on their own pleasures and did not give anything to the peasants.
ОтветитьI definitely prefer sticks of butter over pounds of gold
ОтветитьA Byzantine always pays his debts!
Ответитьlet me guess.....a shit ton.
ОтветитьDidn’t realize Europe had enough gold deposits / taxable sources to produce the tribute outlined in this video.
ОтветитьI mean 3 billion in 300/400 years isn't that much
ОтветитьDidn't have men choosing the bear rather than use the metric system on my 2024 bingo card but here we are
ОтветитьNice
ОтветитьThe more Byzantine Roman videos the better. If you your writers haven't read it i recommend Anthony Kaldellis’s book Romanland: Ethnicity and Empire in Byzantium, it will be useful in your future videos. It discusses about the Byzantine Roman identity, who was included and who was excluded etc.
Ответить🙏👑🏆🏆💯😎😈
ОтветитьI wish Rome and Persia became allies. What a tag team duo. They would have held it down…
ОтветитьI dont care how many bears or how much butter it weighs, tell me how many bars of gold it is! 😂
ОтветитьIf the Byzantine Empire of Justinian hadn't fallen we would be at Mars right now
Ответитьone calculation is missing: how much of GDP had paid.
Ответить6000lbs of gold a year isn't even a day of Ukraine aid...a bargain
ОтветитьWhy did the Eastern Roman Empire become Byzantine? Isnt this nonsense?
Ответить3 billion dollars? US spent 3 trillion to remove to hand Afghanistan back to the Taliban
ОтветитьWonder if they spent all that money on the army would they have been better off.
Ответитьbyzantine empire : if you can't defeat your enemies give them money to leave
ОтветитьIn terms of Philippine pesos, 1 US dollar is equivalent to Php57.19 and if we convert that rate to the said currency, it is Php218,223,314,400, million times more than what "VP" Sara spent in her confidential funds
ОтветитьTelling us that you calculated the amount of tribute Byzantines paid their enemies on the title; as soon as the video starts you start explaining that total amount of tribute couldn’t be calculated due to lack of historical records. Also explaining that tribute paid to ‘minor’ enemies are out of the scope the video. Guys you made a clickbait of a video. Do your job diligently or don’t put in pompous remaks on the title
Ответитьthe amount of gold explained by :
dollars ❌
grizzly bears✅
shaquiille o'neals✅
sticks of butter✅
Awesome video I was thinking I would love to see a video showing later crusades and subsequent reconquest of Jerusalem to the fall of Jerusalem to kwaresmians (butchered spelling sorry) and fall of acre and all mainland crusader states.
ОтветитьStop the annoying clicks, swooshes, pops and other constant emphasis noises.
You sound like Fox news circa 10 years ago, and who learned and stopped all those annoying noises. You?
The tribute's in 6th and 7th century was paid in lightweight solidus(nomisma) of 20 or 22 siliquae (one siliqua was 1/24 of a solidus)
You are an excellent history chanel
Great vid. 4 billion doesn’t actually seem like that much, especially if it kept you from having to muster your troops and equip them. They also didn’t have to pay mercenaries, and the Byz had to do that a lot throughout most of their history as the lone Roman Empire. There were less and less professional Roman soldiers in the legions every year. And just feeding an army was incredibly expensive. I’m not surprised they chose to pay at times.
ОтветитьHistory of Byzantium podcast: and then the Romans debased the coinage…
ОтветитьThat is why the Roman empire east & west fell. They would rather pay Billions to their enemies rather than investing into their own population for fear of the elites loosing their superiority over the masses.
ОтветитьYou can put a zero on the end of that dollar value estimate if you take into account the purchasing power lost by decoupling dollars from gold.
Ответить"Your yearly subscription of Attila+ has expired"
ОтветитьThe "juice" that the Easter Roman Empire had was emence
Ответить48 Shaquile O Neals .....
BRUH
Lmao excuse me? The REAL middle men of the silk road was and always has been known as the Parthian or Sassanid Iranian empires. Nice try to rewrite credit!
ОтветитьNow do the United States
ОтветитьBulgaria - the sworn enemy of the Eastern Roman Empire. Continuation of 7 centuries lead a conflict for the supremacy of the Balkans and subsequently for the legacy of Rome and the power over the world known to us. How many nomisms, centaries and perpers did the Romans give to the Bulgarians as a tribute for propitiating them. The first people, the ancestor of the Scythians, Sarmatians, Huns, Avars, Magyars, Uzis, Pechenegs, Kipchans, Cumans and all known and unknown steppe peoples - the East/Barvaricum, superior in every sphere to the West/Romulum. Think and you will find the silent words for which the heritage of God (Bulgarian) is revealed!
Ответитьi feel like simple multiplication isn't enough. i know there isnt a clear way to calculate inflation since those ages, but considering the gold supply being much lower than today, the actual cost is much more than 4 billion.
ОтветитьTheres a modern state near that área that only has to sneeze to receive 3 billion dollars in trib- er, support from the USA
ОтветитьCall me crazy, but it seems the persians were dominant than the Romans
ОтветитьIt’s diplomacy by other means
If War fails to buy time then negotiations tributes sometimes faltering if the foe returns away or weakens
Nevertheless a stratagem with Ummayeds close calls especially during the siege of Constantinople then the Abbasids only to be fully conquered under the Ottomans whom benefited from the gold tributes the most including some Byzantine princesses given away to Sultans occasionally !!!
East Roman Empire Byzantine was maybe top 2 or 3 impressive Europen Empire in History .Legendary !
ОтветитьThe Byzantine be like hey thief take the tv and get lost, next night take the sofa and get lost, night after night they said take this, take that finally they said take Constantinople itself to the Ottomans and they get lost.😅😅😅
ОтветитьSilly video
ОтветитьI'm a Turk with Greek DNA so basically I'm a Muslim Eastern Roman. Lol
Ответить