Комментарии:
Birds of a feather just gone platinum- mate u have no clue!
ОтветитьA lot of people might disagree with you, but in retrospect, a Light to Decent 7 is correct to me. Replayability wanes after a 5th listen
ОтветитьThis was the first video of yours that I've come across, and I'll be avoiding all others at all costs moving forward. I'm not even a big Billie Eilish/FINNEAS fan, but your commentary comes off as pertentious. You reek of someone who only drinks expensive cocktails. When we're all at the beach/river/lake drinking cheap beers, do us all a favor and stay home.
Ответитьmusic major here, this is by far her and fineas’s best work yet.
ОтветитьWow, I was absolutely loving the instrumental on Diner! I was really surprised by your reaction to it.
ОтветитьFir me it’s an 8. It’s a very, very good album
ОтветитьYou can’t compare Happier than ever with this album. They are completely different. In fact, she made 3 completely different albums which is really something nowadays when artists tend to repeat the formula. She takes risks. Always. You underestimate her. This album is not “perfect” (what’s that???) but it’s a solid 8. Perhaps even a 9
ОтветитьIm so intrigued, searched reviews for said album from the usual publications, Rolling Stone, Billboard etc.. nothing came up, at all, except you. I dont know you, but I really appreciate your eloquence and articulate easy-flowing verbage. I am going to press pause as I am on a run in the mountains of Puerto Rico, but I am intrigued and, for reference, an OG fan from 2017, and Birds of a Feather brought me back to her (as opposed to any song post-fame). Into it, into you. Cant wait to dive deeper into to your prowess and, the album.
ОтветитьLight 7?
I never expect 10s and 9s, but to give an album with some of Billie’s most intimate and strong compositions to date such a rating is sad. Not all songs resonate with me but the fact that this album contains these gems should at least get rid of the ‘light’ description 😆
With all due respect melon, you just don't get lesbian culture :P
ОтветитьWilfrid Coves
Ответить“which is a munch anthem” yes thank you anthony
Ответитьfully agree the diner was a cheap attempt at something they’ve done much better in the past. i think they liked it as an ode to their older stuff but didn’t fully commit so it fell a little flat
ОтветитьI'm lowkey mad she didn't call it, "When We Fall Asleep In The Ocean Where Do We Go?"
Ответитьur take is wrong
Ответитьthis album is a 10....
ОтветитьCommon L from Anthony what is this
ОтветитьIdk man this shit was really damn good I’d probably give it a 9 or 10
ОтветитьRitchie Knolls
ОтветитьBirds of a feather is what made me start liking Billie Eilish
ОтветитьAbsolutely loved this shit. One of my favorite records of the year. Jack Antonoff TAKE FUCKING NOTES that is how synths are supposed to sound. Immaculate writing and production throughout. I absolutely loved the debut, but this might be even better which is saying something on her talent alone. Unreal she is still just 22 yrs old.
ОтветитьStamm Corner
ОтветитьMADMADMADMADMADMAD
ОтветитьI absolutely LOVED it.
ОтветитьRowe Lakes
ОтветитьCool man! you better rank the new glaive when it drop tho
Ответитьi dont understand honestly WHY THE FUCK ARE PEOPLE HATING ON BITTERSUITE?! dude i mean that intro!!!! and the outro!!! how can't you love that song mannn...
Ответитьi really dont listen to much pop at all, but this album is excellent and i would definitely give this a 9 for sure.
ОтветитьFamtano is such a jerk. No matter how good and album is from a popular pop singer is he'll rate it on the low when the album deserves so much more. This guy needs to go 🙄
ОтветитьI completely agree, but I think confusing song writing needs to be added to that list for why it's only a 7.
She claims she strives for ambiguity to allow the listener to project their own feelings on to her songs.. yet at the same time, most of her wording is Strangely specific.. and leaves the listener feeling like they're out of the loop on something..
Like listening in on someone's inside joke..
And I surprisingly love the diner.. fho I agree with all its flaws.. I just really missed creepy Billie.. and I accept it's campines!
Making reviews must ruin all enjoyment that comes from art. I prefer to listen and experience than talk in theory, criticizing artists
ОтветитьI think Birds of a feather is my favourite track of the year. It felt like a song to cruise and get the feels too. Kinda reminds me a bit of Dido or Natalie Imbruglia with Billie’s groove with the Finneas awesome production.
ОтветитьI came here bc Apple Music said that it’s the best album of 2024. And saw he gave it a 7. I stopped watching his reviews bc he’s harsh on albums I like. This makes me feel better that I don’t love shit like daughters or whatever weird thing he praises 😭 still love ya Anthony
ОтветитьIt’s consistent, it has decent writing, solid production for the most part, but it just fell flat for me, nothing really clicked at all, I feel like there’s just so much better the genre has to offer than this, I agree with the 7 score.
Ответитьits so boring and bland people judge it based on one song birds of a feather which is the best the rest is so sleepy and boring no replay value either
ОтветитьDude is really shitting on album of the year. 🤦🏻♂️
ОтветитьBottom line is..fantano wants finneas and Billie to box themselves into the sound they had on her first album. Doesn’t want any growth. 🙄
ОтветитьHow did this get 7/10 and beyonces album gets 8/10…
ОтветитьThe real AOTY..
ОтветитьThis take is accurate & you’re all mad about it
ОтветитьYou are a waste of space
ОтветитьI dont think you could do it better
ОтветитьI don't think ya'll understand how high a 7 is from Fantano
ОтветитьWhy be a music critic if you have no musical appreciation and just want to use vague and uncommon words? Baldy needs to go away and be a failed novelist instead. He gave 'Brat' a 10, when the whole album is <3min SFX 'songs' with weak vocals. Also, I thought everyone knew Finneas does most of the important 'writing' (composition, and he did production - Billie chips in too, but he's mostly responsible). Not saying a 7 is a terrible score, but this guy's just guessing from a narrowed view and understanding of what makes music good or bad. With a bit of 'look at me!' deliberately thrown in. I doubt he listens to albums properly either (especially if he's 'dropping needles' on vinyl - the worst medium for sound, apart from cassettes, possibly). You need to give albums probably 10 good loops.
ОтветитьCHIHIRO IS A BANGER!!!
ОтветитьThe more i listened to some of the songs in the album, the harder it got for me to sit through it. It personally hit hard with “The Greatest”, “Birds of a feather”, and “Blue”. I kinda have a love-hate thing going on for this album. Since it made me cry a lot
ОтветитьYou already know this because you're stuck up. You missed what makes original songwriting
ОтветитьThis album doesn't necessarily have bad reviews, but I feel like it's been catching strays that it shouldn't be catching. I was expecting an 8 or above.
Ответить