Комментарии:
I think sometime around when you bought the office... your tone/demeanor changed and I felt you started to come off as inauthentic and I stopped consuming / engaging with content as much. I would just want you to approach your channel like you like it again.
Ответитьif you did a weekly mini painting walk through, i feel like you can hit a lot of variety while getting a repetitive vid cycle. An A tier Miniac walkthrough with mini variety is something the community desperately needs. I hope i can see that when i come back! keep up the solid content my guy!
ОтветитьOut of sight, out of mind. You showed the largest problem you are having, not enough videos. You basically have 1 video every other week, when you clearly did better when you had a video every week.
ОтветитьYou just popped up in my feed for the first time in forever, I'm not watching anywhere near as much hobby stuff as I used to. But I just clicked on it and remembered why I enjoy watching your videos so much, you're just fund to watch. Stay cool and best of luck with the renewed vigor!
ОтветитьThis comment is probably going to get buried, but I'd really like to see some board game streams or Battle reports with you playing!
Ответитьinteresting concept about 'content whiplash'. If I consider my own habits, I only subscribe to channels with the understanding that not ALL of it is for me, but there's enough within my wheelhouse, and enough that will also stretch my comfort zones. So overall, I appreciate the 'whiplash', and I'm relieved to know the variety helps you too.
ОтветитьYou have not showed up in my feed for a very long time. Good to see you again, my fiend.
ОтветитьGonna nerd out for a sec about algo stuff. There seem to be a lot of creators that have produced videos over the past 2ish years noting a decrease in views/ad revenue. The general trend seems to be threefold.
1. 2020-2021 is a wildly unrepresentative time period for many (most?) creators. YT's ad revenue 4Q2020 was almost twice what it was 4Q2018 and then had risen another 30% by 4Q2021. People talk a lot about 2020's impact, but 2021 was arguably worse because of the different variants. And had a higher pandemic mortality than 2020. Revenue drops off 4Q2021 and doesn't rebound until 4Q2023. 2022 establishes a more consistent and predictable baseline for your views and this lines up with ad revenue as well. Additionally, YT's total user count is up by about 25% in 2022 relative to 2019, with the biggest spikes being 2020 and 2021. 2022 is slightly down from 2021.
2. The algorithm absolutely favors videos with consistent production schedules. Your new, consistent schedule is being rewarded by the algo. Anecdotally, I see you in my feed more now.
3. If your subscribers don't click (because you've deviated from your normal programming), the algorithm goes, "hey, if Miniac's viewers aren't super engaged, I shouldn't push this to new users." This feeds back into your point about changing in your regularly scheduled program hurting you. Basically, the algo wants you to design your content for what your current subscribers want to watch, at which point it will start pushing your content to non-subscribers. The algo wants to see engagement from your established community first. It also wants to push new content, as you've seen from video trends.
All that nerd stuff out of the way: you got this. And I'm looking forward to being here for the ride. Rock on, brother.
Thanks for your great inspirational work.
No need to apologize for whiplash. I think it is a result of the algorithm and I hope you can continue to expxlore the stuff that gets you excited and that you enjoy much deserved success!
keep going, bro!
You should join Nebula
ОтветитьI don’t think content whiplash is a major issue tbh. I personally enjoy the variety with your videos, and it’s part of why I keep coming back.
ОтветитьYou've popped up back in my algorithm after awhile just now. What happened? I loved your content, it's a great way that helped put me to sleep. I ended up watching your videos several times lol
ОтветитьDude you just have to be consistent. 12 videos vs 64, the optics alone
ОтветитьShould turn some of those evergreen videos into shorts.
ОтветитьGlad yo have you back full time. You're one of the guys who taught me how to paint minis back in the covid days. Look forward to seeing lots more of you
ОтветитьDude, I absolutely love this video. Not a lot of creators out there telling us why they’re doing what they are, you’re a man of the people Mr Poirot.
ОтветитьDon't wanna be rude about it, but as long as you don't talk about the games and focus on the hobby, then that's awesome
ОтветитьEntirely off topic, but is that a Christ's nails pin on your shirt?
ОтветитьI have not seen this channel much so i cannot tell you what you did good or bad, but i love minies and painting so you'll get a sub from me, i look forward to see more from you ^^
ОтветитьLove it! keep up the great work. I'll be here no matter where you go with the channel, I just love the energy.
ОтветитьI really don't paint or play Warhammer but I still poke my head in now and again, partly because I think this stuff is cool and partly because I like you as a content creator. You're thoughtful, experienced, and seem like you're enjoying yourself. Keep it up.
ОтветитьEvery channel is down compared to pandemic bro
Ответитьyou're dope Miniac. Always
ОтветитьHere’s a fun fact: this is the first video of yours that I’ve watched from beginning to end. I got bored with the face painting with a beginner video. BUT this came up on my video queue so I watched this, and that’s funny, because I’ve listened to you and Jon for about 6 months now working through the whole TUP back catalogue. I’m up to May 2023.
ОтветитьMy viewing of all the mini related channels, even the one I patron with has dropped because my disability has decreased my capacity to paint and craft
Ответитьengagement
ОтветитьCan you paint some battletech mechs? Asking for a friend ...LOL
ОтветитьA video a week would be great but it's honestly whatever you want to do, man! We're here because we like your stuff. And I've honestly been surprised to never see you do a Nord ad or whatever, we know you gotta make that paper!
ОтветитьHell yeah, excited for what's to come baby
ОтветитьWe want to see what you're painting, and it doesn't need to be overthought. I know some folks will complain and and say you should paint stuff they can order, too, but at least they're engaged, and at least you can look for and recommend similar models that are available at the time of the video. I loved your wife's painting video, and would love to see videos where she slowly improves her painting over time. It doesn't have to be her, but she is pretty great. You did a video about the best non GW minis a while back, but I don't remember you really painting those. Paint em! We are here to see Scott paint, put his glasses upside down and do a muppet voice, and sneak in opportunities to love on metal music. Not every video has to make new territory--there's satisfaction in routine, but it seems you're already on that path.
VPN, meal plan, audible, and broadcasting kit sponsors seem to be a safe bet even though they're not hobby related. Stay away from mobile games, plz. Don't get over analytical about spokesperson ethics like Goobertown. Most of us understand you are a business and need to make money, but also be at peace that you will take criticism for it. Criticism is a constant (just like I'm offering in this comment).
Glad to see you doing what is best for you Scott!
ОтветитьThe face painting video was really useful because you didn't assume knowledge and showed the entire process. Keep doing that!
ОтветитьYT is kind of a beast. Everybody peaks, and I’ve heard YT does have a period of time after which they promote you less. Topic interest fades. Topic interest gets more competitive. A lot of YTs either burnout by themselves or become a small business. I see you have chosen the latter. Definitely stay consistent, pursue your passions when you can and try not to let every stat and performance kill your spirit.
ОтветитьI recommend doing some more collaborations. Crafsman Steady Craftin, Jazza, RP Archive, Black Magic Craft, Table Top Witch Craft, Table Top Time, and the heavily underrated Wyloch's Armory just to name drop a few.
ОтветитьHonestly, I think the channel is great. I wouldn't change much, but the higher frequency posting is much appreciated!
Ответитьbased dota shirt
ОтветитьI'm confused, because I thought they were supposed to be like an ebb and a flow of things
Ответитьi know ur glad trump got re-elected son
ОтветитьSo im not sure if this is just me or if others are the same but the main thing that has stopped me watching my "usual" miniature painting channels is the fact that either what I want to learn has been put out already (ei various primaris marines) or the main fact that a lott of mainstrean channels dont do videos on horus heresy, which I switched to during 10th after finding heresy more fun to play. Ok, 40k is the main game in miniatures, but for someone trying to watch more heresy/fw style schemes I find myself going away from who I used to watch a lot as they keep just doing 40k items which I have little interest in. Or they do a very generic heresy segment and then never return to it which is slightly dissapointing
ОтветитьMore content is definitely better than nothing or less
Personally I would like to see fun miniatures to paint or board games that you are interested in playing and see your genuine interest in them. If you come off as bored or faking it then I lose interest.
I haven't watched in a while. So long in fact that I didn't know you had a kickstarter. lol
ОтветитьOver a thousand comments. You’ll never see this one, lol. I’ll type it anyway. I like the content in your videos; I think you produce useful painting advice. I don’t like you screaming at me at the end of your videos or… I can’t remember, but I’m willing to bet there’s obnoxious music at the top of each video too. That literally makes me pause to think whether I want to click on your thumbnail. I know there’s going to be something good in the middle but at the front and back of the show it’s going to be super-unpleasant. Make of that what you will. Full disclosure: I want to punch Uncle Atom in the face every time he says, “P-chow”. It’s the worst. I agree with most of his opinions and gaming interests but that p-chow b.s. just makes me see red. Have a good one! 👍😁
ОтветитьVery cool and mature of you to address what's going on with your channel, making adjustments and being transparent with the fans about it. Much appreciated
ОтветитьI want to give you money for a "Backlog Golem T-Shirt" but they're sold out ... =(
Ответить