The WORST Eliminations from Every Total Drama Season

Haven’t finished the reboot seasons (following max’s release schedule) but I think I was the most disappointed with MK’s elimination. The subtle sabotaging behind the scenes would’ve been a really interesting and unique villain arc. And though I appreciate Julia, it just feels like something I’ve seen before.

I think Max was the most unfair elimination. As much as I dislike him, Chris was just like, “no evil, bye for no reason”.

The real reason Noah's TDWT elimination is so frustrating is how forced it all is, honestly. Team Chris got Zeke just like they were supposed to, then Chris changed the wording to "find a criminal," then pushed Duncan back in with them and didn't let him get cut. Super clearly felt like they just wanted to be done with Noah, and then following that up with Tyler being the next gone meant the game was basically nothing but the usual main characters + Al/Sierra/Cody for the entire back half. Least Heather's role was great all season.

If any elimination was BS in RR it was the Rockers. Rock as this hypercompetent dude, Spud starting to come into his own as a worthwhile partner after being carried throughout the first half, they make it to the end in the nick of time against the stepbrothers, who were underrated but at least their arc was clearly done... And then Don just randomly declares this the only double elimination leg in the entire season, and they're gone just like that. It was real frustrating, especially with how many non-eliminations there were throughout.

I'll defend the Best Friends going out early precisely because they seemed like such Protagonisty material, though. The rumors are that they and the Sisters were going to be the original finalists, and that's just... both way more predictable and way less fun than the Surfers/Police/Ice Dancers final three we ultimately got.

Honestly both of Tyler’s eliminations were pretty bs. Loved his character and I think his eliminations were pretty unfair

It feels like the black contestants get done dirty imo-

Courtney deserved it, What? Are we not watching the same show?

DAMIAN NEEDS TO WIN REBOOT SEASON 3. 💯

I’ll say this, no matter how much of a terrible person Amy was, you cannot deny that she was cheated af. Tricked out of the show, then voted out immediately the second she came back.

Sammy deserved to take the win, and Amy deserved at least merge to become a better twin.

Revenge of the island is brick and Ann Maria for me

I thought Gwen's elimination on All Stars was ridiculous.

The Lashawna in Island was crazy. Still I would argue that Owen should have been kicked off in the first elimination round, not Ezekial.

Here's my opinion for the ridonculous race. I think that Owen and Noah should've been eliminated in "I Love Ridonc and Roll," with Mickey and Jay going farther. But, make "Got Venom" a non-elimination and make Jay or Mickey get too injured to continue. It could be like, Mickey fell from a really high tree or the got teampled by some komodo dragons, then have them agree to have Owen and Noah be brought back, because they would've seen how much Emma misses Noah. Then, have both The Reality TV Pros and The Sisters be eliminated in the Hawaii episode, a final five, down to a final three.

Watching season1 and 100% Cody… leshawna continuous says how much of a threat heather is, yet voted Cody off? If they wanted heather gone they could have with Cody’s vote but they didn’t for some reason

About the Leshawna’s VA thing, yeah that’s bullshit. Both because the main writer of S1 confirmed she was supposed to be booted off 5th anyway, and second because that’s just not how animated projects work. The writing always comes first, then comes the voice acting and then the animation. If Leshawna’s VA had to leave, the writing wouldn’t have changed anyway, so that’s just a rumor that came out of nowhere and people popularized it because they are simply ignorant on how producing an animated show works.

Team Heathers elimination was the worst
👇

For me bridgette could get more screentime in action especially in world tour i could rlly see her developing a relation (friendly) woth leshawna gwen or courtney and she'd manage to get further

The funniest part about Lindsies elemination was her 🤬

Yeah no Nichelles elimination was fair. It was her own fault for even falling for it. Her own stupidity brought her down because shes been doing nothing but bashing Hollywood every chance she gets and thinks that they sent her a contract on an ISLAND and knew exactly which bed was hers. Her falling for this is on her. She is dumb

The goths in RR were so robbed because they had the stuff to go to the finale but were screwed over by the ice dancers

I loved LeShawnas and elimination, then again I find her overrated

Courtney’s elimination I really don’t mind, Harold had to do it

Lindsay should’ve got 7th and Izzy should’ve been 9th

Lindsay’s was ok, it was funny, odd but funny

Owen’s was really bad

Noah’s definitely wasn’t a good elimination

Harold’s was bad, he should’ve made it further, I just like Harold

Gwens was ok

Bricks was horrible to watch, he needed another chance, he is more of an All Star than Sam

B needed to go early

Dawns elimination was really bad, Scott shouldn’t be allowed to create fake statues

I love when Duncan gets eliminated, I really hate Duncan

Heathers was bad, really bad

Alejandro’s was mid

Jasmines elimination was amazing, I dislike Jasmine

Maxs was really bad, he needed an episode without Scarlett

Devin and Carrie are overrated and should’ve gone earlier

Mickey and Jays elimination was horrible, they were my favourites and needed a chance

Zee went in the oddest way possible

Wayne and Raj’s was mid

Damien was mid

Nichelle’s was good

Damien’s was ok

Bowie’s was ok

My take:

TDI - Ezekiel, Katie/Sadie, Trent, Leshawna
TDA - Trent
TDWT - Ezekiel, Leshawna, DJ, Gwen, Sierra (I REALLY don't care for this character, but Chris being an ass is never pleasant), Cody
TDROTI - B, Dawn, Mike
TDAS - Duncan , Gwen
TDPI - Samey , Ella, Dave (yes, he eliminated himself but what drove him to leave was just wrong).
TDI23 - Caleb, Nichelle, MK, Emma (to some extent), Millie
TDI24 - Millie , Damien

Sorry but Courtney had it coming in island. She dodged 2 eliminations because she was more popular than the characters on the hot seat lol. Zeke was an idiot and Tyler actually DID his challenge or attempted it.

actually leshawna was supposed to be eliminated in a fashion challenge where she wins immunity but gives it to gwen and gwen betrays her thats where the episode title is from

Courtney's elimination wasnt unfair it was shocking

I never had a problem with Brick’s elimination. It felt in character for Jo and Lightning to vote him off for costing them a challenge, regardless of how deadly it was. It also feels like a turning point for the season, with the antagonists starting become more ruthless as the merge drew closer. I like Brick, but his elimination was well timed and well executed in my eyes.

About an Elimination: Harold's Action Elimination was unfair cuz of Owen making Harold kill Duncan's Spider

Courtney's elimination in wourld tour was also unfair

bro this isint tdwt its ttd

Amazing Video🤩😮😂🥺😔😊❤️

I don't think anyone thought Zee was being malicious when he joined both alliances. They just realized that he was too nice and because of that, he could betray both alliances by helping the other. No one wants an ally who's going to help the enemy, even if he helps you too.

Owen's elimination in Action is still one the makes me upset. I feel like they were to smart here with the idea of everyone voting off Cortney. The idea of everyone being so smart and actually wanting to vote her off for being a bitch in one episode was annoying. And generally this is where Courtney just becomes intolerable. Also it would've been funny if she was here for only one ep then got elminated in that episode. I mean the only thing I will say is this lead to Owen later in the season but I couldn't stand how unfair it was just so they didn't give her the boot in her first ep like Eva.

Do be honest, i would have given one of the spots for worst season 1 eliminations to trent, he only got booted off because heather got lucky, and yes i know they kissed but heather forced him to kiss her

Noahs elimination in tdwt was so unfair (in my opinion) this is bc in island he was kinda a jerk and not a team player, but in tdwt he actually fixed his mistakes and became an actual good team player or a charecter that you could cheer for at some points, now no he didnt deserve to win or get into the finals but he did not deserve to get out in i believe episode 13, noah is my favorite character like alot of ppl, i dont think he deserved to win (but that would have been cool ngl) but his elimination was quite anfair. Chris explains that the goal was to catch the ripper....NOT DUNCAN, team amazon found duncan and didnt suffer elimination but team...im not even gonna say the name but that team suffered elimination AFTER DOING THE CHALLENGE CORRECT also it sucks how duncan, tyler, and Alejandro voted him...like what did noah do to duncan or tyler.? Just bc he was correct abt Alejandro manipulating contestants into getting kicked thats y he got out- noah in tdwt had one of the most unfair eliminations, also its like duncan took noahs place even tho he quit in the first episode.

Man the reboot seasons were a nice touch having Bowie and Raj hook up. That aside the ridonculous race season, i was praying for devin and carrie to win that. they were the best in my opinion. all that chemistry and build up to devin finally admitting he loves carrie was just awesome. that and i’m a sucker for childhood friend love stories.

Scary girls' elimination makes no sense season 2 who agrees with me she actually did her part in the challenge

All the way back in season one The saddest elimination was Tyler

I still don't get Noah elimination at all

for noah's elim in world tour... it was annoying and forced. noah was only taken out of the game because the writers wanted to add duncan back, so, they decided to make Noah randomly suspicious. they would've won the challenge anyway, they caught ezekiel and that was the main objective, it just shows the writers didn't care at all about noah's elimination. they should have worked more with noah being suspicious of alejandro. in Slap Slap Revolution noah asks why alejandro is trying to motivate the other team, they could've added a confessional of Noah in that episode saying something is wrong with alejandro. there was so many times where it was painfully obvious, and noah being classed as "The High IQ" he should have been able to figure something out and have a more relevant and interesting plot line then being a forced out player. and if they really needed him gone that much they should have had him win the comeback challenge at least, world tour could've been better. merge could've been noah trying to get alejandro out for revenge, heather and noah could've teamed up, owen told duncan what noah said, so that could've been another alliance. there was so much wasted protentional for noah that annoyed me in world tour. i don't think anyone would've mind such a change, hell, noah doesn't even need to be in the final four he could be elimated along side duncan in the episode he was eliminated.

(sorry for ranting)

mk should be on atleast season 1's worst elimination..

In RR I think the rockers got kicked unfairly. They watched a replay to add time to the episode then kicked them out in a double elimination.

TDROTI Mike's elimination was also unfair

Brick was done dirty. He's probably my fav in ROTI aside from Maybe Zoey. I also wish they brought him back for all stars and NOT SIERRA!

Bro sierras was one of the worst eliminations because like all she did was just blow the plane like

You dont wanna know my rage when brick got voted out he was the goat

Uhm excuse me i belive you forgot izzy from tdwt

Leshawna elim was absolutely damaging! I felt like she was the best in szn 1!

I think you make a disagree, but I will tell you the reason so talk to iron. I think that you can throw in Ella because Ella Ella song in it for me.

Personally, I Always considered that Courtney should have been first eliminated in TDI and All-Stars...In the first season she escaped just because Ezekiel said the worst thing at the worst moment, And in All Stars, Courtney was the one who put Lindsay to drive the carriage, but Lindsay voted herself again...🤦‍♂ (And I think that what happened in All Stars was just an Easter Egg for the first episode of TDI with Courtney escaping from elimination, so Lindsay was a perfect contestant to All Stars, but was brought just to be eliminated first)