Комментарии:
The music is terrible!
ОтветитьStolen art from Guatemala. Sad .
ОтветитьHi ma'am I have 5 heads here and 1 jar can you explain to me what is this?
ОтветитьInteresting that the same people are creating the same type of wares yet are called reproductions or fakers of THEIR pieces?..... it belongs to those who created it not those who put them behind glass, calling reproductions or fakes of the same people making their ancestors wares is irresponsible, maybe old and newer is more truthful
ОтветитьAbsolutely wonderful!
Ответить❤❤
ОтветитьI find hilarious that the archaeologists didn’t believe the mayas were telling the truth at first, not until they actually found a vessel with chocolate remains 😂
ОтветитьWhen you live in the mountains or forests whistling is vary helpfull
ОтветитьWe usually use fire to melt materials but we put clay in fire to strengthen it.
ОтветитьVery well done and use of ceramic pieces chosen was great!
Ответитьinteresting but nothing about African clay .
ОтветитьPaul Day's stuff is phenomenal!
Ответитьthis narrator has a voice like John Candy!
ОтветитьThe piece shown from minute 1957 is called, in Spanish "huaco silbador" . How do you say "huaco" in English?
Ответить. On seeing this collection I hear in my ears a phrase Hændel included in his Messiah: "Marvellous! Wonderful!"... a great Collection and a great video. And it is evident that the curators love intensely the material they are describing and explaining.
Everything is beautiful.
I collect porcelain and I have also worked with clay for some time.
Obvious that those scenes were of the New World.
ОтветитьPlastic is a very poor analogy for the secretive invention and production of porcelain. Nobody tried to keep the manufacture of plastic a secret. They just patented their particular method. The invention of the atomic bomb is a much better analogy.
ОтветитьThe way archeologist use to date ceramic is wrong many toltec copies are fake and and specialist dont make any différence fakesome in the metropolitan museum in the us .... i know the guy who make them
ОтветитьVery interesting
ОтветитьI lived next door to the Gardiner 10 years ago and had wandered through a few times but didn't have this level of understanding - guess it's time for another visit. So cool to see an in depth look into the collection, thank you!
ОтветитьIt's not trumploy... it's "trompe l'oeil" which directly translates from French to fool the eye.
ОтветитьStarting with making "mud pies" as a kid, clay has fascinated me into my senior years. Ceramics was my concentration in university, and with that came a much broader appreciation of the many expressive forms obtained by the medium of clay. The Mayan tamale plate is absolutely stunning!!
ОтветитьThank you for amazing info. & museum.
It's sad that beautiful Rococo & Viennese pieces along with Chinese creations have to suffer being anywhere near ugly 20th century so-called 'modern artist' kindergarten-level messes: late comer are oft such disappointments!
💞
ОтветитьGreat museum. And that whistling piece was fascinating. :) The Colima repro I have, I only wish to be real. Another tip for the hollow ones would be residue of insects inside which could indicate age.
ОтветитьThe way the narrator said "Islam" . . . and the multiple times they zoomed in on the black face comedic puppet... and the lady talking mindlessly about "im not exactly sure what they were used for" ..
ОтветитьOk then.
Ответить💖💕
ОтветитьMurph why
ОтветитьWtf Murph
ОтветитьDevelopment of luxurious pottery (among other luxury goods) doesn't prove society's sophistication. It proves society's stratification, division, development of rich, privileged and idle minority in power of the vast majority of the society which it is exploiting and violently subjugating in order for it to cater to the whims of the former, while not allowing it to participate in any of the sophistication and luxury mentioned above.
ОтветитьThank heavens pre-columbian or any other pottery can't be melted and turned into something else, like gold could, or re-cut and polished to be reused to adorn jewelry like precious stones could be. Otherwise we'd never have seen a single piece of it in its original form nowadays. What a shame the native American civilisations didn't use clay to adorn themselves and create holy artifacts instead of gold.
ОтветитьMany of the Latin American pieces look very humorous to me. I think those ancient peoples must have had great senses of humor. I imagine they must have cracked themselves up making some of those pieces.
ОтветитьHow did Canada get Mayan pieces? Those pieces should be in their own countries.
ОтветитьWhat if an earthquake hits the museum? All the displays breaking🤔 The Battle of Britain sculpture is amazing😊
ОтветитьAll of the mesoamerican objects in this museum come from looting and pillaging archeological sites, museums muts be decolonized.
ОтветитьGoodness, this is repetitive and slow! I kept waiting for more substance
ОтветитьThank you. This is marvellous. More, please
ОтветитьYou don't seem to have Terracotta collections in the museum.
ОтветитьThese museum Curators handing "very rare' pieces of pottery without gloves points towards how curators always elevate themselves above all of us normals. "We curators touch you serfs don't touch".
ОтветитьI would love to see this museum in person someday...but if that doesn’t come to pass this certainly is the next best thing. I learned so much. Thank you for sharing such an informative and interesting video.✨
ОтветитьThat was a very interesting summary of the Gardiner Museum in Toronto. Its always so fascinating to hear the knowledge and pasio of the curators, archeologists and experts. Two annoyances - I'm not sure how much voice work the narrator Shawn Devlin does - but his voice was quite jarring; as well - the background music - annoying and constant.
ОтветитьIt’s time we stopped ‘gauging’ societies on arbitrary scales, which inevitably lead to a claim of cultural superiority, and start thinking of cultures as constellations rather than continuums
Ответитьis that anthony bourdain s voice
Ответить