Комментарии:
Fantastic movie.
ОтветитьOne reason this movie gets crapped on is the dialogue. I think a lot of americans are used to clunky hoorah pro american machismo types of lines, but for the rest of the world its seen as very odd and clunky dialogue, it just really really stands out and feels unnatural.
ОтветитьI don't know if anyone has mentioned this, but it really bugs me how in their attack on the island of Roi, the Japanese fleet is anchored near a bunch of cliffsides. Roi (now Roi-Namur after the two islands of Roi and Namur were combined in 1944) is a part of Kwajalein Atoll. The main characteristic of coral atolls like this? They're completely flat. Not a mountain or cliffside in sight.
ОтветитьGood old b of ordnance torpedoes they bounce well
ОтветитьIts sad that the navy had to do life firetests inside a warzone because the FUCKING Bureau of Ordnance COUNT BE ASKED TO TEST THE SHIT THEY GAVE OUT PROPERLY BEFORE!
ОтветитьThe remarkable crib ostensibly jump because hedge coronally examine mid a mellow rose. abandoned, willing church
ОтветитьGreat film.
ОтветитьYou won't see animals like this ever again
ОтветитьDid yall noticed the sound is quite not weird
Ответитьlove how the subtitles are set up for some one who can only understand english spoken but not japanese, but can only read japanese not english
ОтветитьBull crap movie
ОтветитьIt's my understanding this movie isn't terribly popular. Historically it is reasonably accurate and represents both side fairly well. However it has been Hollywoodized fairly heavily with catchy dialog. The officers dress uniforms look like they were slept in. Maybe they were trying to depict clothing materials as they existed in the early 40's. Accuracy of military protocol was lacking. In the Navy you don't salute indoors or in the interior of a ship. You remove your cover indoors. I'm not a fan of CGI but understand it is the now thing. Still, every time I see it applied at this level I can't help but think I'm in a video game. The 1970's version was much better. Tora Tora Tora is the ultimate naval war movie. Very historically accurate, great special effects, great shipbuilding, and no CGI. I watch it every December.
Ответитьwhy do I feel that the sound is a water tap
ОтветитьBalls of steel
ОтветитьThe best War movie I have seen…bash me all you want…I will stick with what I said!!!
ОтветитьI want to see yamamoto assaniniation based movies,is this movie name "Midway".
ОтветитьWoody as Chester Nimitz is the worst casting call in history.
ОтветитьEd Skrein did a respectable job as Dick Best however his dialect is terrible. British actors often overdo it on the American accents and they come off sounding like a bad impression of the Dead End Kids.
Ответитьi hate the allies i wish japan won midway and coral sea.
Ответитьso fucjing no one's gonna say anything about the audio? ok.
ОтветитьAm I the only one having audio issues with this clip?
ОтветитьThe sound on my phone when I saw this clip sounded like nice squeaking
ОтветитьWhy do I feel like that a lot of people haven't noticed the almost complete lack of American fighter planes in this movie?
All we see are Bombers of various types. We should be seeing F4F Wildcats and maybe a few Brewster Buffalos.
Underated movie..
ОтветитьYou Tube purposely screwed up the sound, Led by the FBI of course
ОтветитьThe audio is screwed up on this
ОтветитьMy great grandfather is admiral bull Halsey
ОтветитьMan re uploaded ot later better audio
ОтветитьThis movie makes me want a movie on admiral Halsey where he’s played by Dennis Quaid again
ОтветитьNo single movie will be 100% accurate. If you want 100% historical accuracy go watch a doc..
Ответить"Ain't they paying us to kill Japs?" If you don't drop a one liner is it even worth it?
ОтветитьBury Murdock writes Dickens wink inc.
ОтветитьThis may not be 100% accurate but I still found this entertaining
Also weren't there wildcats that were used at the battle of midway ?
I still don't know how the airplane missed the carrier. Bruno's balls must have created its own gravity field and should have pulled the plane right into it.
ОтветитьI didn't like this movie. I know many people do and I am not here to flame on them but I didn't buy most of the casting. My main impression is the director shot it like a video game. It also had rather standard hero tropes that are old and tired. It wasn't as historically accurate as its fans seem to want it to be. Thought the music was unexceptional. I'm already not a fan of the director and I think he was 'miscast' as well for this pic.
ОтветитьSuch a great movie and one of the more accurate war ones made. No need to add a fictional love story or some made up characters to add conflict or drama. All of these guys were heroes.
ОтветитьAudio sounds like some one running water in a sink???
ОтветитьThe last part with Bruno - 100 % true , the tail broken off, promotion - everything except admiral Halsey called him over the PA system
ОтветитьYes, the American torpedos were as likely to be alive as they were dead or the other way around.
ОтветитьNo sound
Ответитьnot getting any sound here
ОтветитьGreat movie. I have watched it multiple times. I overlook most irregularities because I do like the story
This scene always bugged me a bit though. They show the carrier in view of the islands. They would never get that close. They would of stayed at least 100 miles away
Also they spent too much time with the other stories which are important yes but not enough on the actual midway battle.
I would of liked to see the attacks on the Yorktown
Stick with the original, no cgi
ОтветитьSaluting is never done indoors in the Navy
ОтветитьTHIS WAS A REAL TIME IN AMERICA WHEN MEN WERE MEN AND NOT QUESTIONING THEIR VALUES AS MEN. THEY DID NOT HAVE SOY FLOWING THROUGH THEIR VEINS BUT REAL BLOOD. NOW THE MEN WANT TO DRESS UP AS WOMEN AND STEAL THEIR GLORY ALL WITHOUT LOSING THEIR MEMBERSHIP TO BEING A MALE FRAUD IN THE SHOWERS!! JUST WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED TO THE OLD HAGS OF NOW AND PROTECTING WOMEN AND AMERICA?? THIS IS HOW FAR BIDEN HARRIS HAS LET AMERICA FALL, SHAME ON THEM AND THEIR SUPPORTERS!!
ОтветитьNow I know where Ron Moore got the inspiration for the pilot of Battlestar Galactica 2002
ОтветитьWouldn’t Nimitz, old salt that he was, have said “I want to know they aren’t SAILING into a trap”? Asking for a friend.
ОтветитьSorry but woody in this role is totally unbelievable. A 4 star general is going to be at least 60 years old or more, but his makeup can’t hide his youth…
ОтветитьHenry Fonda as Nimitz was better
Ответить