Tudor Black Bay 54 vs 58: The Ultimate Showdown

54 looks more beefy in terms of proportions. Might get one soon.

The BB58 is hands down THE BEST watch I've ever owned. It's gorgeous

This video gets a thumbs-up because I agree with your wife.....wholeheartedly.

I have bought. Part by part, the 58 may win, but all together, the proportions of 54 are better. Great watches anyway.

I was a 58 man until I wore the 54 for a week. Strange things happen when you get used to a 37mm watch....

I have the 58 in blue and one in the black top watches in my collection, love them!

I tried on one of the BB 54's recently, I thought it looked and wore amazingly well, even on my 8 inch wrist. I'd definitely buy one

Totally agree. The 58 is a better looking watch!!! congrats!

Great watches. The 54 looks perfect on my medium 7.5 wrist.

Love the Sports Almanac notebook cover, Russ! With how much you’ve enjoyed the Blackbay 58, I wonder if you’ll ever consider going for a modern Sub? They’re still well under 41mm in diameter despite what the specs said and the 12mm thickness combined with the slim midcase make them feel and look almost as good as their 5 digit predecessors. The bracelet articulates in a sublime manner and the bezel clicks like a dream. I think you’d love them if you got the chance to wear them for a while. l because those are the traits you love from your 58.

i only wish bb58 is brushed on the sides like pelagos, but pelagos is not steel. is there any tudor steel case and all brushed finish?

Best comparison review I’ve seen of these two models side by side to date! I’ve got a BB 41 so I reckon the 58 would be more my size, however love the new look T fit clasp on the 54! What the watch the watch said as usual comedy gold! 😂

bb54 for me =p

54 all the way. If the BB is supposed to be a retro watch, might as well go all the way. The small size vs. density/heft ratio really gives a sense of quality and solidity.

The size decrease and T-fit also makes it a LOT more comfortable

Enjoyed the video 😊 Congratulations, i haent ever seen a watch review video before where I disagreed with every single thing said 😅 i dont think the BB54 and BB58 look that different in size, much prefer the glossy black dial, the BB54 looks more interesting, on the fly adjustment is important and overall the BB54 is just better 😅

Any discount code for BQ Watches? Or just tell them you sent us kind of thing

Or just go for the WatchDives BB54 homage.
You get the gilt and red triangle if you want them AND you get the Seiko VH31 quartz with its superb accuracy....

This guy gives me anxiety. 😅

I agree Russ - I have a black bb58 and the only thing i prefer about the 54 is the bracelet clasp.

Your wifes comments kill me because she is the same as my wife 😅

No comparison, the 54 is much better

Great comparison, I think you nailed the it. The BB58 has a bit more personality, some of which could easily translate to the slightly more sterile 54.

But there's something kind of magically addicting about the 54's proportions.

I just got into watch collecting. I've loved watches since I was young but I never had anyone teach me or bring deeper into the world. AMZWATCH brought closer to a community and hobby I always wanted to get into more and that is incredibly meaningful to me !

I'm genuinely impressed with how close AMZWATCH were able to replicate every aspect of this very very goofy looking classic watch.

BB54 hasn't left my wrist in over 18 months - proportions, weight, look are all superb. And I prefer the fact that the bezel insert doesn't have the guilt colourway, which makes the dial look like it has some patina. I winner in my book.

I’ve got both the 58 and the 54 and while both are terrific watches, I’m definitely partial to the former. The 58 has a bit more “personality” to it with the warmth of the gilt dial/indices and the red triangle up top. And despite the hype of the T-Fit, I prefer the smaller original clasp on the 58.

But I’ll still wear the 54 from time to time and enjoy the wearing experience. I could see myself eventually moving on from it, though.

What the wife said is so funny

Got the 54 after an Omega SMP and I really enjoy it. Precisely for the size, the simplicity and that amazing bracelet. And I chose it instead of the 58 tbh

I like a bigger one, it looks and feels better

● I've never seen a video where the true hue, tint & colour of the gilt hands, dial furniture and bezel marks of the BB58 come through as they do in person.
● It's rose/pink gold, not yellow. You might like this or not care BUT you could also find it looking terrible.
◆ Go to an authorized Rolex & Tudor dealer. Have the BB58, BB54 and a rose gold Rolex model placed next to one another.

BB58 & Longines Spirit 37mm = my perfect combo. 7.25inch wrist. Great video!

I have the 58 (black/gilt) and I’m really tempted by the 54. I think the silver numbers on the bezel looks better as well as the lack of hash marks. I also think the dial looks more interesting with a nice sheen and more glow to the printing. Oh, and the T-fit of course!

I debated this dilemma and ended up with a Ranger. I love it, it's a fantastic watch.

Where can i buy those nice murals at the backround?

As Tissot exploit the PRX and the BB Beckham bandwagon rolls on and on

I prefer the 58 but like you would happily have both if money were no object. 54 on rubber and 58 on a bracelet

The Blue 58 for me, on the blue soft touch strap - can't get enough of it! 😍

Hi, I had the 54 but I found it very difficult to operate the crown, because of that, I sold it.

Great video MWC, I have the 79220N eta rose smiley. To me it is Tudor perfection, all the subsequent variants have thieir pros and cons, however any black bay offers unbelievable value for money.

BB 54..!

Great review! I was all for the 58 until I tried on the 54… to me the 58 felt like the more juvenile little brother trying to be like its older sibling. I don’t say that trying to knock anyone or their enjoyment of anything at all, just how I felt :) loved the vid as always!

Very nice. Thanks for the great comparison! You should have told your wife, “Boring?! But I’ve bought both of them…” 😆

Best affordable BB54 alternative is Hamilton Expedition 37mm (black)...

BB58 for me every time.

Tudor black. Bay 54. VS. 58. The. Ultimate. Showdown

Ever since I bought a watch from AMZWATCH, My question is if it's this hard to tell them apart, what is the point of owning an authentic watch?

It always amazes me how much beauty and precision are added to the parts of AMZWATCH's watch 99% of people will never see.

God!!! AMZWATCH Who would have thought those gorgeous watches go for that low!!!

Funnily enough it was the red in the bezel that put me off the 58 when it came out.. still don’t like it

Southern Fairy😂😂