Комментарии:
Australia can learn from this ethnic autonomous system as we approach the Aboriginal voice to parliament referendum vote. Baby steps at least.
ОтветитьAll I know they are few thousand ethnicity in China.
ОтветитьSurprised!
Ответить我觉得评论区的各位都可以用中文表达
ОтветитьAs a Chinese myself born and living in Asia I never knew anything about "HAN" Chinese, when I first heard of it in the 2000s I thought it's just another Chinese like canton, hokkien, tiewchew and thought what's the big deal? Sadly it seems more like something for the western bigots to use as a divide and conquer weapon.
Funny that Russians, Chinese and Mongols back in the days conquer to unite therefore now has a large nation while in the west it's divide and conquer to conquer divided nations that was conditioned to hate each other.
🙂🙏👍👍🙏🙂
ОтветитьAmazing job, Andy! I like this new series!
ОтветитьHan Hakka Chinese here,you know about that andy..HAKKA CHINESE PEOPLE..
ОтветитьThe White Supremacist West doesn’t care. They’ll only pretend to care if they can use minorities for Terrorism & Separatism.
ОтветитьFunny how Western hawks keep screaming on Tibetans and Uighurs when majority of them have never been to China let alone understand what is going on there. The only words West love to propagate are authoritarian, police state, genocide, religious freedom, human rights which quite comically sounds pretty much like the West is! And never never forget the last extremely important propaganda LBGTQ
ОтветитьHaving 91.1 % of the majority population is a homogenous population and not diversity (according to the scammers of the world).
And how many of the remaining 8. 9 percent are foreigners born outside of China? (In sweden, sadly, 20 percent of our current population is born outside of Sweden and then moved here. Add to that, also 2nd generation migrants and their children. The Swedish "majority" population in our third largest city is already a minority. In 5-10 years (with current trends) this will happen also to our 2nd largest city. And within 15-20 years (probably sooner) we will also be a minority in our largest city and capital of 'Sweden' (or what's left of it).
Can you do a video about Mao Zedong and Chinese communism?
ОтветитьYet the western media accuse China of oppression of minority ethnic groups and cultural genocide. They are either ignorant or pretend to be ignorant.
ОтветитьYou know what they see when they see this? Great! We can divide & rule 'em.
ОтветитьVery interesting and informative. Thanks Andy.
ОтветитьThank you again, Andy. This is one of the hurdles communicating with people outside of China, particularly westerners. When Chinese use the word “Chinese”, they mean “people of China”, ie, all ethnic groups; whereas westerners use the word to mean Han Chinese specifically.
ОтветитьHello Andy, an excellent presentation with one small misleading statement. Religion being protected by law, that is only true if they are registered with the government, Christianity is restricted as well by law, bibles for example can only be used if they are printed in China, Christians communication is restricted as well. Christianity is growing despite the government's strict laws to limit its growth. Language is always a problem as it is constantly being modified the words may be written the same the sound is constantly changing. Television has had the greatest impact on stabilizing the spoken word. Some people that lived just 20 miles apart could not understand each other, with one central language and Television it gave people a tool in China to communicate with their neighbors. English as well being taught in China has had a major impact in communication. Before Television the United States had the same problem. Med-western English was chosen as the model and is understood in every state. Overall you did a good job on this.❤
ОтветитьFantastic lesson!
ОтветитьReally appreciate Andy's introduction of the minority groups of China.
ОтветитьThe most amazing thing is, despite comprising as much minority groups as 56, there is no race discrimination in China.
ОтветитьIn China, children can inherit ethnicity from either parent. if you are unsure(say, orphaned), you can always identify as Han. Here’s the question, what do you call a child with Chinese and Russian parents. A Han (majority) or Russian (minority)?
ОтветитьIs Catholicism not just one division of Christianity - like Orthodox and Protestant?
ОтветитьTo be more precise; China's official governance recognized the ethnic minority people of China AND afforded them Affirmative Action (优惠政策) benefits which predate the American AA by a decade, and to take it up to another level, China's ethnic minority people are also afforded Liangshaoyikuan (兩少一寬) which is something you'll not see in the U.S. judicial system; imagine less culpability for misdemeanors and even felonies if you're an African-American, Hispanic, Asian-American / Native American etc... that's what China has!
ОтветитьIt's the same as in Britain... Welsh, Irish, English, Scottish and now half of Eastern Europe!
ОтветитьReal diversity. Not just some corporate rubbish agenda pushing
ОтветитьAnd I guess West is gonna take the reduction of Yi to just 22 tribes as evidence of cultural genocide... LOL. Great report, please keep it up, thx
Ответитьyeah, don't you know? me and Clint Eastwood are both just squinty eyed people. 🤣
ОтветитьThanks Andy
ОтветитьJust to put the whole thing into perspective, I feel the whole race thing is really kind of different in the Chinese context. Concept of ethnicity among Chinese (including, and perhaps especially among those in the Chinese diaspora) is more of a cultural thing. Being Han Chinese really is a self-identification for the most part. Being Chinese is really a cultural identification. Which is why I believe why Martin Jacques calls china a civilisation state. Han, strictly speaking are people who descended from the core group in Han dynasty. However, historically, there had bean many people outside of central plain that invaded and ultimately assimilated and adopted the Han culture. Notice southern and northern Chinese actually can look significantly different from one another. Interestingly enough, the word for Chinatown in places outside of China is really called Tang Town (唐人街), again, refer to people of a long dead dynasty. In fact in south east Asia, ethnic Chinese dialect there often refer to ethnic Chinese as Tang People rather than Han People. Russian word for Chinese actually refer to another long dead dynasty for a people that were almost completely assimilated that it doesn’t even exit as part of the 56 official nationalities. In any case I feel the whole 56 official nationalities is probably an outdated way of classifying people. Take for example, in 2006 a group of people descended from an invading Nepali army from a few hundred years ago were granted Chinese citizenship, because there are no Nepali among the 56 officially recognised group they were classified as Tibetans. As china become more developed, there bound to be more inward migration, and eventually China will need to grant citizenship to people that has no official classifications. For example, hypothetically speaking, if one day you were granted a PRC citizenship, will you just be randomly assigned one of the officially recognised white people in china given that there are no official classification for Kiwi or English. You might well be classified as a Russian.
ОтветитьHighly racist. Fiercely nationalistic. Thoroughly brain washed. Prone to rudeness. Hygiene a problem. Yep, pretty much the same.
ОтветитьWhich Chinese? From where? LOL
ОтветитьYOUR knowledge exceed me as an 'ethnic' Chinese diversity. Thumbs Up.
ОтветитьITS SHOW JUST HOW IGNORANT THE WEST REALLY ARE
ОтветитьCan you tell us more about Qin Gang ? I know CCP makes him disapeared even erasing all mentions of him in a typical communist fashion. But now they start to reappear, kinda of funny, since you are directly connected to CCP I thought you might have some insights about this pathetic move ?
ОтветитьWow! There's northern and southern Han! 56 minorities.
ОтветитьMuch Gratitude For Your Diplomatic Endeavors Mr Andy Boreham ✌️🇺🇸💫
Ответить刚从B站看完😂
ОтветитьYet Western media still assume there is human rights problem in Xinjiang, despite the Uygur and the other 54 minorities all grow faster than the Han majority.
ОтветитьLovely!
Africans must learn from this.
❤❤❤❤Thank you Andy,🌷🌷🌷🙏🙏🙏㊗️🀄️🇳🇿🈶🈵🉐🧧🌺
Ответить❤
ОтветитьI Definitely knew not all Chinese are the same, just as not all people in USA are the same! 🤙❤️🔥
ОтветитьYes, tehy are all brainwashed by the ccp dogs
Ответить👍So our North-East India is belong to CHINA from the begining
Ответить谢谢,作为一个外国人,能客观叙述中国。
ОтветитьIsn’t Catholicism and Christianity the same thing
ОтветитьMy dna test shows that I am from all parts of China from western minority to northern minority to Korean to Vietnamese on the south! OMG
ОтветитьChina was not always the large country it is today. In the past, it was made up of hundreds of small states, each governed by different emperors and own difference languages. These states were often engaged in conflict, as each kingdom sought to become the dominant power. This historical background explains why there are so many languages spoken among the Chinese people today.
ОтветитьDo you know how many languages or dialects the han speak?
Ответить