Комментарии:
😁
ОтветитьIt’s incredibly moving living with your dead in the same house, we strayed away from community
ОтветитьBeautiful documentary - thankyou so much for sharing with English subtitles! Not all of us think of ancient peoples as 'less than' us, no matter how often we were told that. It just never made sense that the people who built the world we now inhabit were in any way inferior to us. I would think the opposite is true. Having to do more would make you an excellent problem solver, which these people obviously were. I LOVE that this is finally coming to light!!
ОтветитьÇok ilginç. Çok teşekkür ederim
ОтветитьAmaizing story, congatulations . Thank you all .
ОтветитьTarihi yeniden yazıyorsunuz. Emeğinize sağlık.
ОтветитьGüzel olmuş, elinize sağlık
Ответитьmen in that culture need to learn to NOT interrupt women every time they speak...
ОтветитьI think they decided this subject was not going to be interesting enough in and of itself without the enticement of a pretty female to drive the archeological storyline. In a way her role is a distraction although they use her as a vehicle to reveal information about the historical site. The approach is stilted and artificial and the focus on her body and facial features are also a competitive distraction.
ОтветитьSuperb...and golden..
ОтветитьExcellent!
ОтветитьThis is mind blowing. What a fascinating documentary.
ОтветитьAbsolutely wonderful documentary, respectfully communicated by all professionals involved, bringing to light fact that these were thoughtful people with love & respect for each other. Thank you 🙏
Ответитьshe’s extremely gorgeous ❤
ОтветитьThank you for continuing to record and show the new Mirazan sites (the original, local Kurdish name for the recent official gov name). Mirazan ("miracle maker"). the local, childless women give offerings at the hill, hoping for a child. The fertility myth of the hills, still lingers. Mirazan is the meaningful, local name for this entire super old civilization/culture. A lot better than the silly name of Gobekli ("potbelly")-- given to it by the ruling government there . I hope you continue showing us more and more of the Mirazan sites as they get dug up
ОтветитьBeautiful! Well Done, Thank You ❤
Ответитьnice voice but damn I wish this was in english. I like using documentaries as background for when I am doing something else.
ОтветитьA wonderful short documentary that would make one cry while watching.
ОтветитьStunning. Thank you vary much for English subtitles. I am geneticists. Because of relatively dry condition some of these bones may still contain DNA. To prevent contamination the best would be not touching them with bare hands at all and do not even blowing on them. We shed around lots of our own DNA. This applies in particular to the locals involved in excavation as these people may be the closest living relatives. DNA analysis may open a new chapter in history of human kind and civilization. This is all mind blowing.
ОтветитьOne thing is certain, modern humans existed 12,000 years ago. It is as if they suddenly appeared, and knew how to build, craft, and draw. They were of the same intelligence as us. If stuck a nuclear scientist in the miiddle of a barren land, he could only work with what he could find. They were the same. They were not primitive at all.
Ответитьhow long until all the migration theories and human evolution are entirely deconstructed and removed from history books, what else is needed a ufo?
ОтветитьAmazing I say.
Thanks so much for the video and info.
DNA çalışıldığını biliyoruz sonuçlarını açıklar mısınız
Ответить❤
Ответитьseems to me that for a long time before true agriculture, hunter-gathers spent thousands of years living a nearly settled lifestyle, the population grew, common traditions and cultural beliefs took hold among ever larger groups of people, it was a long transition phase from hunter-gather to Neolithic farmer and from the evidence we now have, the Temple, and the changing spiritual beliefs that it represents was a huge part of that transition, like Klaus Schmidt I think the Temple was first, before cities, before writing, before agriculture.
ОтветитьBeautiful film! Thank you!
ОтветитьI love that there are people out there who care about the history of humanity.
ОтветитьAmazing documentary about an amazing discovery. Thank you for adding the English subtitles.
Ответитьçok çok ilginç. Türk hükümetini tarihine sahip çıktığı için takdir ediyorum!!!
ОтветитьThis is so well done. These were obviously an amazing settled people… i think we owe more than we know to these ancestors.
ОтветитьBulgular cok onemli suphesiz, ve bu belgesel de onlardan haberdar etmesi acisindan degerli. Yalniz daha teknik bir belgesel aydinlatici olurdu. Mesela araya serpistirilen garip romantik laflar yerine, roportajlari yapan kisinin anlatilanlari anlamli sorularla detaylandiracak kadar arkeoloji alt yapisi olabilirdi.
ОтветитьTurkish
ОтветитьThanks for a wonderful documentary. Very interesting and informative. I was spending my summers when i was much younger in a small village only 20 km from this area. You guys did a very good work with this documentary. Thanks again ❤
ОтветитьWow!! ... that was amazing ........ Thank you .. Much love from Dublin Ireland ❤
ОтветитьI missed my calling. 46 year old hard working Dad who can't seem to get enough info about ancient civilizations, history and archeology. Thank you so much. This was very well done and I'm hooked.... Also, I think I just fell in love.
ОтветитьBinlerce yıl öncesinden yaşam izleri olan bil bölgede yürümek ve bunu bilmek yada anlamaya çalışmak. Var oluş nedenimizi sorgularken, düne dünden bu güne ve yarına
Ответитьellere dillere saglik muazzam calismalar🍀
ОтветитьAmazed
ОтветитьOn binlerin dönüşünde ki kitabında tmm burayı anlatıyor.
ОтветитьBRAVO!! EXCELLENT!!! An absolutely stunning film! WOW! Thank you kindly for the subtititles! Really, really, reeeeally nicely done!!!
Ответитьgreat stuff. these people were the fathers of the culture of Europe, middle east and the Mediterranean.
ОтветитьEmeğinize sağlık teşekkürler.
ОтветитьI couldn't get past the first few seconds. What a pretentious selfie of a documentary. Maybe you got to something substantive eventually, but I was disgusted with the beginning. It's not about you.
ОтветитьTurkey will keep giving if they keep digging, the gateway to asia and one of the greatest civilisations and some the longest/oldest inhabited lands
ОтветитьThank you so much. I have been an amateur archaeologist since my brain began to question everything about my ecological niche. But here in the West, we are burdened with left-hemispheric dominance, (imho), which leads us to separate, classify and categorise everything within our rigid perspectives, usually at the cost of seeing the ‘Big Picture’.
Do you realise that the work you are involved with, in Anatolia, has completely undermined, the whole of our Western Archaeological ‘Discipline’?
Well done!
And you interpret the material evidence, and convey the larger picture, in such an understated manner, that your story seems so genuine and accurate, from a human nature, viewpoint.
I have learned more, in your one video, than I have previously, in reading a hundred microscopic analyses, of any one settlement, since you interpret with a keen understanding of inter-generational human dynamics, married with an impressive, broad spectrum, of knowledge.
It was a pleasure for me, and will inform me of how to best present my forthcoming videos, on the Picts, of Scotland.
(I think a woman’s perspective, (the Matriarch), is essential, if we want to communicate a more holistic and authentic narrative).
Thanks to both of you and your learned Team.
MTR Independent Psychologist.
That tall lady with long hair is drop dead gorgeous!
ОтветитьSo what's the point of the chick wandering around at the beginning? Got to get a little sexy something into your documentary???
ОтветитьWord is out that between 40 to 80 other Gobekli Tepe type sites have now been identified by either initial test excavation trenches or ground generating radar in that part of Turkey.... Some dated thousands of years before Gobekli Tepe...with prehistoric animal life associated.
Closed meetings behind doors at UNESCO.
95 percent of the site is buried unexcavated underground. With a dozen or two dozen similar temples next to each other... If this was in South Africa and remains and relics were declared proto-San there would be untold millions donated in funding and excavation equipment from UN UNESCO and the First World Nations. All prestigious Universities would have dispatched Phd encampments. Some Nations may venture to declare an additional "Gobekli Tepe Month".
The appalling nature of something from the age of giant Prehistoric Animals and Ice Age with squared masonry stones and 3D relief carvings of a magnitude larger and almost 3 times as old as Stonehenge's 1/3 smaller crude phallic pillar slabs... Before religion was invented, near Mt Ararat, covered with animal life, the Cradle of IndoEuropean Caucasian origin..
Is enough for the Scientism Mafia Skeptical Inquirer gatekeepers to reach for the Kaopectate by the armful.
Wrong ethnicity, wrong mountain, wrong religion...
Making Turkey an offer it can't refuse...
Put excavation on the back burner and the silence of crickets chirping, hoping it would go away. Just not PC egalitarian enough.
Incredible documentary! Amazing archeologist! Intriguing questions from lovely lady whom enabled us to see humanity
If you need support to further your work, you should do something.
Toprak çekiyor
Thank you all so much for your lovely comments! Your feedback is very valuable. Can you share the link to the documentary on your social media accounts to support us?
Ответить